My watch list


Genetic defects without consequences

mRNA of defective genes pushes compensation mechanism

© MPI für Herz- und Lungenforschung

Genetic compensation does not appear in the absence of mutant mRNA. The figure shows the vascular system in a two-day old zebrafish embryo. When the mRNA derived from a defective gene is absent, the vascular system does not develop properly (lower image).

15-Apr-2019: Many diseases are caused by genetic defects. However, their severity can vary among individual patients, so that even mild forms can occur. Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Heart and Lung Research in Bad Nauheim have now decrypted a molecular mechanism responsible for this phenomenon. Accordingly, the mRNA of the defective gene ensures that related genes are activated thereby compensating the defect. The researchers hope to make use of this mechanism for therapeutic approaches.

Defective genes are responsible for a number of serious illnesses. One example is cystic fibrosis showing severe symptoms due to a defective protein. This malformation in turn is caused by a defect in the coding gene. The responsible genes for most this kind of diseases have been tracked previously.

As an experimental approach to assess the function of individual genes, researchers often modify genes, e.g. by introducing mutations. However, such a modification does not always have an effect on the organism. For instance, experiments in animal models frequently show that the expected effect does not occur after a genetic switch-off of genes. The causes are largely unknown. One possible explanation is that if a gene product fails, its tasks are taken over by other, similarly acting proteins. Understanding the molecular mechanisms that can lead to this kind of compensation for the failure of individual genes is thereby a very important question.

Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Heart and Lung Research in Bad Nauheim have now used advanced tools like CRISPR to decipher such a molecular machine. The consequences of a genetic defect are thereby mitigated by related genes, which are now increasingly active. "Based on data from previous studies, we assumed that a defect in a gene could result in related genes being more active in expressing their gene products. These proteins, which are related to the original protein, would then take over its tasks," explains Mohamed El-Brolosy, a member of Didier Stainier's department and first author of the study. "A complex molecular machinery is behind this genetic compensation." Stainier's group has now been able to decipher the complex processes using experiments on mice and zebrafish.

Related genes compensate for genetic defect

The Bad Nauheim scientists investigated zebrafish that had mutations in different genes. “We started by looking at many different mutations in specific genes and found that not all were equal”, El-Brolosy states. The ones that tended not to show abnormalities had something in common: El-Brolosy and his co-workers found that in these mutants increased amounts of mRNA of other members of the gene families were produced. “When we provided functional protein back into these mutants, it did not have an effect on the increased transcription levels of the other potentially compensating members of the gene families. From these and other results we concluded that the trigger was not the faulty proteins," according to El-Brosoly.

It turned out that the mRNA was always unstable in mutants that did not show abnormalities. "Our data indicated that in these cases the mutant mRNA was more rapidly broken down," said El-Brolosy. From this and other observations, the Bad Nauheim researchers concluded that mRNA is signaling on a second level. “Our data indicated that the mutant mRNA was signaling to other, non-mutated genes to take over.” 

Missing signal for compensation

This hypothesis was tested in a rather elegant and powerful way, when by means of an additional genetic engineering approach, it was no longer possible to generate mutant mRNA. "Since there was no mutant mRNA, there was also no one to signal to the other genes. In consequence, we did not see compensation in these animals", said El-Brolosy. With seemingly dramatic effects: For example, the development of blood vessels in zebrafish embryos with a relevant mutation was disturbed only if the mutant mRNA was missing. If, as mentioned earlier, the mutant mRNA was present, the vessels developed normally, because the related genes became more active. “We propose that the molecular machinery that normally ensures that only flawless proteins are formed has a second essential function: it helps to activate related genes as an alternative to the defective gene, thereby compensating for the genetic defect," Stainier concludes.

For a number of diseases, this mechanism could be protecting some individuals from developing more severe symptoms. Stainier's group plans to investigate this hypothesis by comparing individual patients with different clinical manifestations. With such an analysis, scientists hope to identify genes that could be used for therapeutic approaches that aim at enhancing an organism’s robustness to a mutation rather than correcting it. “This study also brings up new and important information about the unintended consequences of genome engineering, and calls for additional investigation before guidelines are even discussed”, Stainier emphasizes.

Original publication:
Mohamed A. El-Brolosy, Zacharias Kontarakis, Andrea Rossi, Carsten Künne, Stefan Günther, Nana Fukuda, Khrievono Kikhi, Giulia L. M. Boezio, Carter M. Takacs, Shih-Lei Lai, Ryuichi Fukuda, Claudia Gerri, Antonio J. Giraldez & Didier Y. R. Stainier; "Genetic compensation triggered by mutant mRNA degradation"; Nature; 2019.

Facts, background information, dossiers

  • genetic defects
  • gene mutations

More about MPI für Herz- und Lungenforschung

  • News

    Cancer diagnosis with a breath test

    “Inhale deeply ... and exhale.” This is what a test for lung cancer could be like in future. Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Heart and Lung Research in Bad Nauheim have developed a method that can detect the disease at an early stage. To this effect, they investigated the presenc ... more

More about Max-Planck-Gesellschaft

  • News

    Direct Observation of Giant Molecules

    The tiny size of conventional diatomic molecules in the sub-nanometer regime hinders direct optical resolution of their constituents. Physicists from the Quantum Many Body Division at MPQ led by Prof. Immanuel Bloch were able to bind pairs of highly excited atoms at a distance of one microm ... more

    Wound healing with the power of nanofibers

    The healing of injuries, especially of severed nerve tracts, nowadays requires complex methods, such as sewing the two nerve stumps together. Scientists from the department of Prof. Tanja Weil (Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research), led by Dr. Christopher Synatschke, have now developed ... more

    Multitasking with perfection: Nerve cell works like 1400 individual cells

    CT1 is different. In general, a nerve cell receives input from a number of presynaptic cells, processes the signals, and passes its output to downstream cells. In the cell CT1, however, each of the approximately 1400 cell areas works like a separate neuron. This allows CT1 to access informa ... more

q&more – the networking platform for quality excellence in lab and process

The q&more concept is to increase the visibility of recent research and innovative solutions, and support the exchange of knowledge. In the broad spectrum of subjects covered, the focus is on achieving maximum quality in highly innovative sectors. As a modern knowledge platform, q&more offers market participants one-of-a-kind networking opportunities. Cutting-edge research is presented by authors of international repute. Attractively presented in a high-quality context, and published in German and English, the original articles introduce new concepts and highlight unconventional solution strategies.

> more about q&more

q&more is supported by:


Your browser is not current. Microsoft Internet Explorer 6.0 does not support some functions on Chemie.DE