02-Nov-2021 - Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg

Study analyzes technologies’ climate efficiency in removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere

One process has similar CO2 footprint to e-mobility

Technologies for the removal of carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere (direct air capture, or DAC for short) are already in use, but neither their actual benefits for climate protection nor their other environmental impact have yet to be investigated. A research team led by Kavya Madhu and Prof. Dr. Stefan Pauliuk from the University of Freiburg (Faculty of Environment and Natural Resources) has now analyzed the carbon footprint of these technologies. To do so, they determined for two common DAC processes - one at high and one at low temperature for capturing CO2 - how high their energy input, CO2 emissions and other consumption factors are to extract one ton, one megaton and one gigaton of CO2 from the atmosphere and inject it into deep soil layers. They also compared these values to key existing technologies and measures for CO2 reduction, such as e-mobility and heat pumps. “The low-temperature process for CO2 extraction proved to be surprisingly efficient,” says Kavya Madhu, "for one ton of CO2 extraction, for example, 0.3 tons of CO2 are currently emitted in the energy and heat supply required for this, and as little as 0.15 tons if low- CO2 electricity is used. The resulting net CO2 extraction of 0.7-0.85 tons is comparable to the CO2 savings from using the same amount of energy for electric cars instead of gasoline-powered cars. They published the results of their study in the journal Nature Energy.

“Several factors for long-term storage are still unknown”

Extraction technologies first bring ambient air into contact with a substance that absorbs the CO2 from the air. In a second step, the captured CO2 is released again in high concentration by heating and then liquefied. Energy expenditures and emissions for the CO2 extraction processes arise in particular from the necessary generation of ventilation, chemical reactions and heating, as well as the injection of the extracted CO2 into deep soil layers. However, according to Stefan Pauliuk, “Several factors for long-term CO2 storage are still unknown or difficult to determine, such as the dynamically evolving CO2 storage capacity of rocks.” 

For their study, the team determined the efficiency of CO2 extraction technologies over their life cycle using a detailed life cycle assessment in OpenLCA software. They calculated the environmental impact of providing the materials and energy needed to build the plants and capture and inject CO2. For comparison with other technologies and CO2 reduction measures, they used existing data from various literature sources, aligned them, and performed their own process modeling to ensure completeness and consistency.

“Given that CO2 extraction is already comparatively efficient, DAC technologies are likely to play a long-term role in climate mitigation as a complement, not a replacement,” Madhu and Pauliuk conclude. “Given the uncertainty of actual scalability, the risks associated with CO2 storage in rock, and the early-stage development of DAC technologies, the use of already established and similarly climate-efficient technologies such as battery-operated vehicles and heat pumps remains urgent.”

Facts, background information, dossiers

  • CO2 storing
  • CO2 extraction

More about Uni Freiburg

  • News

    A molecular machine at work

    The greenhouse gas nitrous oxide (N2O) is produced as a by-product of industrial processes and through the use of fertilizers in agriculture. It is making a steadily growing contribution to climate change and the depletion of the ozone layer. It is so chemically unreactive that it remains i ... more

    New discoveries about the origin of the brain’s immune system

    What gets into the brain and what doesn’t is strictly regulated. Researchers at the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Freiburg have now studied phagocytes that coat the blood vessels in the brain and reinforce the blood-brain barrier. As the scientists from the Institute of Neuropath ... more

    Lung Tissue from the Lab

    Laboratory studies of lung tissue usually require the removal of large amounts of human or animal tissue. Now scientists from the University of Freiburg’s Faculty of Medicine have succeeded in collaboration with American researchers in generating tiny quantities of lung tissue, so-called or ... more

  • q&more articles

    Modular biofactories at the cellular level

    Despite his love for complex molecular architectures, this „dyed-in-the-wool“ bio-organic chemist has never embraced the conventional segregation of synthetic polymers and bio­logical macromolecules. All molecules are composed of atoms, after all. Why make an artificial distinction? Why not ... more


    From a pluripotent stem cell a muscle cell or a liver cell can form, which despite their difference in appearance, are genetically identical. From one and the same genotype, therefore, the most diverse phenotypes can be formed – epigenetics is making it possible! It is a very exciting area ... more

  • Authors

    Dr. Stefan Schiller

    Stefan M. Schiller studied chemistry at Gießen (Mainz, Germany) and the University of Massachusetts, majoring in macromolecular chemistry and biochemistry. For his doctorate in biomimetic membrane systems he worked till 2003 at the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research in Mainz. Researc ... more

    Julia M. Wagner

    Julia M. Wagner studied pharmacy in Freiburg (licensure 2008). Since 2008 she is a PhD student and research assistant in the group of Professor Dr. M. Jung. Her research focuses ­on the cellular effects of histone deacetylase inhibitors. more

    Prof. Dr. Manfred Jung

    Manfred Jung is a graduate of the University of Marburg, where he studied pharmacy (licensure  1990) and obtained his doctorate in pharmaceutical chemistry with Prof. Dr. W. Hanefeld. After a post-doctorate at the University of Ottawa, Canada, he began with independent research in 1994 ­at ... more

q&more – the networking platform for quality excellence in lab and process

The q&more concept is to increase the visibility of recent research and innovative solutions, and support the exchange of knowledge. In the broad spectrum of subjects covered, the focus is on achieving maximum quality in highly innovative sectors. As a modern knowledge platform, q&more offers market participants one-of-a-kind networking opportunities. Cutting-edge research is presented by authors of international repute. Attractively presented in a high-quality context, and published in German and English, the original articles introduce new concepts and highlight unconventional solution strategies.

> more about q&more

q&more is supported by: