My watch list
Detecting and manipulating ions

Detecting and manipulating ions

From Potentiometry to the Nanoscale

Xiaojiang Xie (Université de Genève), Prof. Dr. Eric Bakker (Université de Genève)

The pH electrode is now ubiquitous for the monitoring of chemical processes. Progress in materials chemistry and fundamental methodology opens the door to new exciting approaches.

The direct detection of ionic species in real time is extremely important for process and environmental monitoring as well as clinical diagnostics. The techno­logical nucleus of this approach has been the ubiquitous pH electrode, which today comes in many flavors and shapes to satisfy each user’s need. Beyond pH, clinical analysis has very much relied on the application of ion-selective electrodes (ISEs), which are potentiometric
sensors as well, but typically rely on different materials. Most scientific progress in recent decades has been with hydrophobic membranes containing lipophilic complexing agents (ionophores) for the detection of a wide ­
range of ionic species, including polyions [1].

Fig. 1 Schematic concentration profiles across an ion-selective membrane used in potentiometry (top) and thin layer coulometry (bottom) shown with the sensor responses on the right.

Can we achieve calibration-free sensors?

Despite this materials success, potentiometry (see figure 1) is not really suited as a robust, calibration-free metho­dology. The potential at the reference electrode is prone to uncertainties and failure and the traditional liquid junction has been difficult to replace, although ionic liquids have recently emerged as a promising material principle to replace the aqueous bridge electrolytes [2].

To improve the robustness of electrochemical ion sensors, new approaches have been explored that make use of otherwise the same materials principles as ionophore-based ion-selective electrodes. They rely on dynamic electrochemistry where an applied potential or current results in the transfer of ions from the sample to the membrane [3]. In the approach shown in Figure 1, the sample solution is brought into a thin layer format, which makes the transfer process exhaustive. This makes it possible to simply count, by integration of the current, the amount of ions in the sample, resulting in a technique that is potentially calibration-free and temperature independent. A side result of the dynamic nature of these techniques is that one changes the information on the sample. Instead of ion activities, one assesses the labile ion concentration of the sample. With hydrogen ion responsive systems, for example, this means that one can detect alkalinity or acidity instead of pH [4]. This opens the door to new direct detection techniques that historically needed aliquots and volumetric titrations.

Achieving ultra-small ion detectors

On the other end of the spectrum, there is a growing interest in the miniaturization of ion-selective sensors
to the micrometer and even nanometer dimension. The most obvious driving force is the possibility to perform measurements in ultrasmall spaces, as the interior of cells, which is impossible to perform with bulk sensors. Micrometer sized optical sensors have been adapted for flow cytometry. Ion-selective microelectrodes and micro/nanosensors that behave on the basis of bulk optodes have been successfully applied in cells to monitor ion concentrations [5,6].

Fig. 2 Picture of ion selective nanosphere aqueous suspensions containing various chromoionophores.

Between electrochemical sensors and optical sensors, the latter may have a brighter future given their compatibility with state-of-art imaging equipment such as fluorescence microscopes. ISEs have been miniaturized for intracellular experiments, but the noise level, detection limit, lifetime and physical robustness are not satisfactory and require operator training. Of course, optical sensors have their own drawbacks, among which their tendency to photobleach and where ISEs still hold an advantage.

Our group has developed a simple and convenient methodology to produce self-assembled nanospheres for detecting metal ions [7]. The process requires dissolving all sensing components together with an amphiphilic copolymer in THF that is injected into aqueous solution. Nanospheres will form spontaneously owing to the hydrophobic nature of the sensing components, giving an average size of about 40 nm that, to the eye, appear just as a homogeneous solution (Fig. 2). However, these optical nanosensors still behave on the basis of ion exchange principles and maintain electroneutrality in their hydrophobic core.

Overcoming the pH cross-­response of optical ion sens­ors

Ion optodes have historically suffered from a pH cross response. Some fluorescent ion indicators also exhibit similar pH interference. To overcome this limit, we have recently proposed an exhaustive sensing mode where the analyte is consumed by the sensor and thereby allows for a pH independent response [8]. Suspensions of ultra-miniaturized optodes are very attractive in this respect since the sensor response is dramatically faster compared to traditional cast films. An exhaustive sensing mode is very useful when the experiment of interest can tolerate the analyte consumption.

In addition to this strategy, one may remove the lipophilic pH indicator dye to mimic the composition of ISEs at the nanoscale. We have recently been investigating voltage sensitive dyes to image the electromotive force of these ion selective nanospheres, converting the potentiometric response to fluorescence readout.

Moving to the future: Blurring the lines between solution chemistry and sensing

Ionophore based ion-exchange nanosensors may contribute to different interesting directions that blur the lines between solution chemistry and chemical sensing. We are investigating ionophore-based nanoprobes as novel complexometric titration reagents [9]. Water soluble organic chelators such as EDTA have been widely applied for chelometry but the selectivity and working pH range have not really evolved in the past 60 years. Ionophore based nanoparticle suspensions may overcome existing drawbacks and potentially replace these reagents.
The complexation reaction is moved from the aqueous phase to the organic nanospheric phase where highly selective ion receptors are embedded. Figure 3 shows the comparison between Ca2+ titrations using EDTA and calcium-selective nanospheres containing ionophores.

Fig.3 Titration using calcium selective nanoparticle and EDTA. NS 1: non-buffered water; NS 2: pH 7.0 buffer; EDTA 1: non-buffered water; EDTA 2: pH 7.0 buffer.

We have recently introduced the concept of photodynamic ion sensors in the form of polymeric films [10]. These sensors can be switched ON and OFF by illumination with light. Photoswitchable dyes such as spiropyrans are used as chromoionophore for this purpose. Under ultraviolet light irradiation, spiropyran will transform to photo­merocyanine which has a much higher affinity for protons. Illumination with visible light can convert the photomerocyanine back to the non-basic spiropyran. When a photodynamic ion sensor is miniaturized into
the nanoscale, it not only functions as a light activated sensor but can also serve as a light responsive tool for ion concentration perturbations in the sample [11]. The light controlled release or uptake of ionic species can potentially form new platforms for uncaging reagents and delivery systems. While these are exciting prospects, one should not underestimate the expected complications associated with experiments in vivo and in other complex media.

The development of new approaches to detect ions by electrochemistry and the miniaturization of ion-selective optical sensors is quite exciting. But much remains unexplored, and future work needs to focus on the understanding of these new sensing tools and their application in demanding areas, followed by identifying the challenges, improving the materials toolbox and demonstrating key applications of analytical importance.

[1] Bakker, E. et al. (1997) Chem. Rev. 97, 3083–3132
[2] Zhang, L. et al. (2012) Anal. Chem. 84, 3461–3464
[3] Bakker, E. (2014) Trends Anal. Chem. 53C, 98–105
[4] Ghahraman Afshar, M. et al. (2014) Anal. Chem. 86, 6461-6470
[5] Dubach, J. M. et al. (2009) PNAS 106, 16145–16150
[6] Thomas, R. C. et al (1975) Nature 258, 754–756
[7] Xie, X. et al. (2013) Anal. Chem. 85, 9932–9938
[8] Xie, X et al. (2014) Anal. Chem. 86, 2853–2856
[9] Zhai, J. et al. Chem. Comm. submitted
[10] Xie, X et al. (2012) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 134, 1692–-16932
[11] Xie, X & Bakker, E. (2014) ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 6, 2666–2670

First publication: Xie, X., Bakker, E., q&more, 2.2014.

Facts, background information, dossiers

More about Université de Genève

  • News

    A Negative Enzyme Yields Positive Results

    Chemistry has provided many key tools and techniques to the biological community in the last twenty years. We can now make proteins that Mother Nature never thought of, image unique parts of live cells and even see cells in live animals. This week in ACS Central Science, two research groups ... more

  • q&more articles

    Combinatorial explosion in separation sciences

    In analytical sciences one of the major goals is to develop and validate methods for the identification and quantification of molecules in complex samples to support investigations in the pharmaceutical sciences, environmental sciences, food sciences, biology and medicine. more

  • Authors

    Prof. Dr. Gérard Hopfgartner

    Gérard Hopfgartner, studied chemistry at the University of Geneva and received his Ph.D. degree in 1991 in the field of organic geochemistry and mass spectrometry. He pursued his formation as a postdoctoral fellow at Cornell University in the domain of LC-MS/MS atmospheric pressure ionizati ... more

    Prof. Dr. Eric Bakker

    is Professor of Chemistry at the University of Geneva. He was educated at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) in Zürich, Switzerland. After his Ph.D. he pursued postdoctoral studies at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, U.S.A. His independent career started at Auburn Unive ... more

    Xiaojiang Xie

    is currently a Ph.D. candidate in Prof. Eric Bakker’s research group at the University of Geneva. Between obtaining his Bachelor’s degree from Nanjing University in China and starting his studies in Geneva, he worked for half a year in WuXi AppTech (Shanghai) and one year and a half in the ... more

White paper


Most widely read

  1. Weighing in the US Pharmacopeia
  2. Biobased raw material flows of the future
  3. Lean lab methods and safety in the laboratory
  4. Animal Venomics
  5. Drug substances in the drug product dossier
  6. Mercury in the environment
  7. Quality assurance in medical laboratories
  8. How GxP-regulated laboratories can use digitization as an opportunity
  9. Perspectives of Computer-Aided Drug Design
  10. Taste and aroma boost in the mouth

Topics A-Z

All topics

q&more – the networking platform for quality excellence in lab and process

The q&more concept is to increase the visibility of recent research and innovative solutions, and support the exchange of knowledge. In the broad spectrum of subjects covered, the focus is on achieving maximum quality in highly innovative sectors. As a modern knowledge platform, q&more offers market participants one-of-a-kind networking opportunities. Cutting-edge research is presented by authors of international repute. Attractively presented in a high-quality context, and published in German and English, the original articles introduce new concepts and highlight unconventional solution strategies.

> more about q&more

q&more is supported by:


Your browser is not current. Microsoft Internet Explorer 6.0 does not support some functions on Chemie.DE