My watch list
The Best Measurement

The Best Measurement

Milestones on the path to a new definition of the kilogram

Dr. Peter Becker (Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB))

It is now more than 30 years since attempts started to find a way of defining the kilogram based on an atomic constant or a fundamental physical constant. Since then, two methods have advanced sufficiently far to make it likely that there will be a new definition within the coming years, namely the Watt balance ­experiment for determination of Planck‘s constant h and the Avogadro experiment for determining the ­Avogadro Constant NA. Both numerical values can be converted to the other by use of the molar Planck constant NAh, the value of which is known extremely accurately. However, until now, the differences between the results of the Watt balance and Avogadro Project combined with the corresponding uncertainties were not statistically reconcilable, a situation which has now changed positively thanks to new results.

In Issue 4/2010 of the periodical Chemie & more, we reported on the successful new determination of the Avogadro Constant. Meanwhile, in Autumn 2011 in Paris, the general conference of the Metre Convention, based on the proposal of its advisory committee, agreed with the concept of linking all base units back to fundamental constants and consequently of linking the kilogram to Planck‘s constant h. However the moment for this new definition will only be reached if the measurement results of both the Avogadro and the Watt balance experiment have achieved the necessary agreement both in terms of numerical value and measurement uncertainty. This means that one of at least three independent experiments must have achieved a relative measurement uncertainty of 2 x 10-8, and the remaining two at least 5 x 10-8. The results must also agree within a 95 % confidence interval, i.e. their “error bars” must overlap. These results will define a more accurate value of Planck‘s constant, which is binding for all users and therefore also for the definition of the mass unit, without measurement uncertainty.

The Difficulty of Counting Atoms

In the Avogadro project, the number of atoms in one mol of silicon is determined. As it is not possible to individually count the atoms, the regular layout of the atoms in a crystal lattice is used. In an ideal case, a silicon crystal comes very close to being a perfect crystal. Initially, the number of atoms in an approximately 1 kg heavy silicon sphere is calculated by determining the sphere‘s volume using a special sphere interferometer and using a (separate) measurement of the atomic volume made using a special X-ray interferometer. The ratio of the two results equals the number of atoms in the sphere. The number of silicon atoms in a mol is calculated by dividing the mass of the sphere, determined by comparison with a standard mass, by the molar mass of silicon. However one difficulty arises: silicon has three stable isotopes with molar masses of 28 g, 29 g and 30 g and it is necessary to know how many atoms of each isotope are contained in the crystal in order to determine a mean molar mass. This is achieved using a mass spectrometer. For the latest measurements, the researchers have produced an enriched silicon crystal, with which a measurement uncertainty of 3 x 10-8 for the Avogadro Constant can be attained. It was not possible to achieve a more accurate result because the oxide layer on the silicon spheres did not have such a ­simple structure as assumed because the polishing process caused a contamination by metal atoms. This brief presentation of the measurement method should not hide just how complex and technically demanding this experiment proves to be. As the Avogadro constant is linked with Planck‘s constant by a precise set of fundamental constants, it is an important input value for the kg definition.

Any research result is worthless if it is not independently confirmed. Therefore, efforts have been made within the Avogadro project to ensure that all measured variables relevant to the result have been measured in different laboratories as far as possible independently and then the results compared and evaluated with each other to achieve the greatest possible redundancy. For two variables, the lattice parameter and molar mass, there has, up until now, only been one experiment in the world as a whole. While the lattice parameter is to be determined by the PTB itself for a second time, various metrology institutes were asked to help in verifying the molar mass of the enriched crystal used. Since then, the Canadian metrology institute (NRC) and the corresponding laboratory in the USA (NIST) have published their first measurement results. Here two things are pleasing: firstly, the results essentially confirm the PTB values. Secondly, where the PTB results are concerned, small deviations from the PTB results were identified, the cause of which can now be investigated.

Photo: National Metrology Institute

Fig. 1 Interferometer for highly precise determination of the diameter of the sphere at the National Metrology Institute, PTB

Values on a Convergence Course

Up until now, two experiments using Watt balances have been carried out. In the USA, a comparable value was published a number of years ago (measurement un­certainty 3.6 x 10-8). Unfortunately this value and the Avogadro value disagree by some 1.6 x 10-7 from each other. Since then, work on this “research” experiment has largely been suspended in order to set up a small robust watt balance for calibration purposes. Hence it will be almost impossible to clarify this discrepancy. Likewise, a further independent measurement using a Watt balance was started many years ago at the British metrology institute (NPL). This numerical value also differed from the American value, although it was within the range of the Avogadro value. However, as the measurement uncertainly was relatively large and was not to be further reduced, NRC took this balance and reinstalled it in its own laboratory, where it quickly achieved new and more accurate results (measurement uncertainty 6.5 x 10-8). In autumn 2011, new data published for this Watt balance experiment and also independent measurements for the isotope ratio in the Avogadro spheres were again pleasing because the results of both experiments could be brought into close agreement.

Photo: National Metrology Institute, PTB

Fig. 2 View of the weighing room during determination of the mass of the 28Si sphere AVO28-S8 (1) using kilogram prototype no. 70 (2), platinum-iridium sorption artefacts (3, 5) and buoyancy artefacts for determining the air density (4, 6)

Final Spurt towards the New Definition

The final stages now involve correction of small discrepancies and achievement of the necessary measurement uncertainty of 2 x 10-8. The Avogadro project plans to reduce its measurement uncertainty from the existing 3 x 10-8 to better than 2 x 10-8. To achieve this, both silicon spheres are to be repolished to improve the roundness and simplify the structure of the oxide layer.

To meet the requirements for a new definition, a successful conclusion to a third experiment for determination of Planck‘s constant is still outstanding. For many years, metrology institutes in Europe have been endeavouring to build Watt balances. To accelerate this process, the coming three years will see a joint project between these institutes and the Avogadro project to deal with possible discrepancies and successfully conduct a third independent h experiment.

Only when all data meets the requirements of the Metre Convention both in terms of value and uncertainty can a remodelling of the SI units and their new definition be completed. Alongside the kilogram, the kelvin, ampere and mole should then be defined based on fundamental constants. The next start-up is already planned for 2014, a new challenge for metrology. Consequently, the coming years up to 2014 will be characterised by a PTB-NRC duel to achieve the best measurement of Planck‘s constant, with the Avogadro experiment currently being in front by a nose.

Literatur beim Autor

First publication: Becker, P., q&more, 1.2012.

Facts, background information, dossiers

  • measurement uncertainty
  • Planck‘s constant
  • Watt balances
  • Avogadro Constant

More about Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt

  • News

    Don't Give the Slightest Chance to Toxic Elements in Medicinal Products

    Lead, cadmium, mercury, and arsenic do not belong in medicinal products. International requirements for the quality of medicines have therefore become more stringent and introduced new control requirements. Hence, it makes sense to use high-accuracy reference solutions with defined contents ... more

    Measurement of the dynamic mechanical properties of viscous materials

    In microsystems metallic components are increasingly being replaced by those from low-cost polymers. For the thickness measurement of polymers, there is now the DIN standard 32567 available, which describes both, optical and tactile surface measuring methods for the precise measurement of t ... more

    The most accurate optical single-ion clock worldwide

    Atomic clock experts from the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB) are the first research group in the world to have built an optical single-ion clock which attains an accuracy which had only been predicted theoretically so far. As early as 1981, Hans Dehmelt, who was to be awarded a ... more

  • q&more articles

    Natural constants take center stage

    The 20th of May 2019 is a special day. From that day on, the old definitions of what a kilogram, a mole, an ampere and a kelvin represent, are history. The future of the International System of Units will see natural constants play the star roles. more

    How the Avogadro constant was measured for the last time

    Since the 20th of May 2019, the mass unit kilogram is no longer defined by the international kilogram prototype but by the numerical value of the Planck constant, the most important fundamental constant in quantum physics. For this definition, the Planck constant needed to be measured with ... more

  • Authors

    Dr. Jens Simon

    Jens Simon, born in 1962, has followed two academic paths as he moved between Braunschweig, Jülich and Cologne. One path led to a doctorate at the Technical University of Braunschweig in German linguistics on the language of the author Arno Schmidt. The other path led to a doctorate at the ... more

    Prof. Dr. Joachim H. Ullrich

    Joachim Ullrich, born in 1956, studied geophysics and physics at the University of Frankfurt where, after graduating in 1983, he also completed his doctorate in 1987 and qualified as a professor in 1994. From 1989 to 1997 he worked as a research assistant at the Gesellschaft für Schwerionen ... more

    Dr. Horst Bettin

    Horst Bettin, born in 1955, studied physics at the Technical University of Braunschweig where he completed his PhD at the Institute for Semiconductor Physics and Optics. In 1990 he joined the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt and focused his research mainly on density measurements. He h ... more

White paper


Most widely read

  1. Weighing in the US Pharmacopeia
  2. Quality assurance in medical laboratories
  3. Drug substances in the drug product dossier
  4. More than honey?
  5. Chlorogenic Acids in Coffee
  6. Mercury in the environment
  7. Securing data jewels within the data lake
  8. How the Avogadro constant was measured for the last time
  9. Fascinating displays of colour
  10. HPLC with non-specific detection in pharmaceutical quality control

Topics A-Z

All topics

q&more – the networking platform for quality excellence in lab and process

The q&more concept is to increase the visibility of recent research and innovative solutions, and support the exchange of knowledge. In the broad spectrum of subjects covered, the focus is on achieving maximum quality in highly innovative sectors. As a modern knowledge platform, q&more offers market participants one-of-a-kind networking opportunities. Cutting-edge research is presented by authors of international repute. Attractively presented in a high-quality context, and published in German and English, the original articles introduce new concepts and highlight unconventional solution strategies.

> more about q&more

q&more is supported by:


Your browser is not current. Microsoft Internet Explorer 6.0 does not support some functions on Chemie.DE